Meeting No: 2010/067
Agenda No: 63
Decision date: 25.10.2010
Decision No: 2010 / UY. of-3302
Firat Construction Tourism Nakliyat Tic. and San. Ltd. Ltd. Sti., Cengiz Topel Cad. Merve (Nazlı Sok.) Özsinankent Site A-1 Block D.3
Tcdd 2. Regional Directorate, Marşandiz Region 06105
Application Date and Number:
Subject to Application:
2010/69927 Tender Registration Number "Rocking, Spur and Drainage Between Irmak-Zonguldak Line Km: 355 + 000-355 + 238" Tender
Review and Evaluation by the Authority:
18.10.2010 date and IY28.42.0102 / 2010-45E no.
Regarding the tender of "Rocking, Spur and Drainage Between Irmak-Zonguldak Line Km: 2 + 29.06.2010-355 + 000" held by TCDD 355nd Regional Directorate on 238, Fırat İnşaat Turizm Nakliyat Tic. and San. Ltd. Şti. upon the rejection of the complaint filed by the administration on 01.09.2010 with the letter of the administration dated 03.09.2010, the applicant filed an objectionable complaint with the petition dated 14.09.2010 and numbered 27563, dated 14.09.2010, which was registered with the Authority,
Examination of information and documents sent by the Administration;
4734 rejects the complaint of appeal by appeal under paragraph (c) of the first paragraph of Article 54 of Article XNUMX;
The decision is appropriate to be decided.
The Review Report and its annexes were reviewed:
In summary, in the appeal complaint; The tender held on 29.06.2010 Hasan Yüksel-Millennium Building Partnership na given the industry a long time is a very important work signatories have as a company subject to tender the work of the quoted price to be done in a healthy manner and handle the quality of work they think will suffer losses, the extreme low interrogation in this case given that they think that the defense is not taken into consideration properly, the administration has expressed this opinion, the labor cost of the construction work should be re-examined by considering the cost of labor and the extreme low defense should be taken into consideration, while the examination of the nearest material supply quarry 30 km away from the work site and sufficient the fact that the second material supply point is located at a distance of 40 from the work site. phenomenon works in the lower layers of rubble, rust, mud and earth to do business using such materials, the quoted price but with the work of the technical specifications may be made to work without compliance, the place was given to the alleged need to take into consideration the complaint to be made in accordance with the technical specifications of the job.
As a result of the following factors to evaluate the claims of the applicant it has been determined:
The tender subject to the application is defined as the construction work of the Irmak-Zonguldak Line Km: 355 + 000-355 + 238, Sliding, Spur and Drainage.
The tender for the tender was published in the Public Tender Bulletin dated 11.06.2010, where 9 tender document was purchased and 29.06.2010 tender was attended to the tender held on 9 by open tender procedure.
Article 19 of the administrative specifications of the tender subject to the application and Article 9 of the tender announcement; “Bidders will submit their bids on a turnkey lump sum. As a result of the tender, a turnkey lump sum contract will be signed with the bidder. " According to the regulation, turnkey lump sum was realized by receiving an offer.
In the unit price descriptions of the tender subject to the application; "BF-1 Excavation (Slope Excavation), BF-2 Narrow Deep Blend Excavation on All Types of Soils (for drainage ditch and channel and head trench excavation), BF-3 150 Dose Grobeton, BF-4 Sand Gravel Drainage, BF-5 200 Dose Grobeton, BF-6 250 Dose Grobeton, BF-7 Q200 Drenflex Piping ”description has been made.
The tender commission has determined that the limit value is 397.483,70 TL for the tender subject to the application and Emba Proje Turz. Const. Tic. and San. Ltd. Ltd. Şti., Hasan Yüksel-Milenyum İnş. Taah. and Nedret Özakın İnş. Taah. and Trade companies to announce their bids.
After the submission of explanations about the question of extremely low bidding, the tender commission; Emba Project Turz. Const. Tic. and San. Ltd. Sti. and Nedret Özakın İnş. Taah. As the explanations of these companies are not appropriate, these bidders are excluded from the evaluation and Hasan Yüksel-Milenyum İnş. Taah. The bid price is above the limit value, Fırat İnş.Turz. cash. Tic. and San. Ltd. Sti. and the second most economically advantageous proposal.
As a result of the tender proposal by Hasan Yüksel-Milenyum İnşaat;
“In the analysis of the work of filling stacked stone with 1 / K quarry stone, which is a TCK pose; For the preparation of the stone, the cost table was presented together with the YMM approved bid invoice from Bor-Beton company for a price of 17.084 TL / m3,90, and OBA İnş. Tic. and San. Ltd. Şti. The cost table is presented together with the YMM approved bid invoice, the transportation of the stone is calculated from the shipping formulas of the Ministry of Public Works and the density of the stone is calculated by taking 3 tons / m13,50 in accordance with the technical specification and the analysis is made in accordance with the communiqué,
2-Iller Bank position 15.23283 The sanding of sand-gravel is the 2010 TL / m25,58 price of the drainage work. In accordance with the Communiqué by adding transportation on the unprofitable price,
3 16.002 200 2010 104,00 TL / m3 XNUMX Dose is the exposure of the Ministry of Public Works. According to the Communiqué, by adding transportation and profit upon unprofitable price,
4 16.003 250 2010 110,13 TL / m3 XNUMX Dose is the exposure of the Ministry of Public Works. According to the Communiqué, by adding transportation and profit upon unprofitable price,
5 21.011 TL / m2010 16,33 price is 2 16,33 TL / m1,25 13,06 2 TL / m16,32 2 16,32 1,25 13,06 2 XNUMX XNUMX XNUMX XNUMX XNUMX XNUMX There is no element to change the price. By adding profit on the unprofitable price, a unit price list is made in accordance with the Communiqué,
6 18.460 2 200 2010 27,06 2 XNUMX XNUMX TL / mXNUMX XNUMX XNUMX XNUMX XNUMX XNUMX XNUMX XNUMX XNUMX XNUMX XNUMX By adding profit on the unprofitable price, a unit price list is made in accordance with the Communiqué,
The 7 / H15.006 1-0 m Trench Excavation of 2-DLH General Directorate is the 2010 TL / m8,59 price. By adding profit on the unprofitable price, a unit price list is made in accordance with the Communiqué,
8-In addition, the relevant company carried out the work of "Rocking, Spur and Drainage between Irmak-Zonguldak line Km: 2005 + 311- 620 + 321" in 700, this work is a similar job, this work contains 21.298 m3 stone with a unit price contract. He has put the progress payment tables of the work with the bet that he has paid. The mentioned job also; It is seen that the construction of rock fortifications, pere coating, stone wall, flat formwork, BA concrete, lean concrete excavation, thin iron filling, the barbecue contains the items mentioned above. The work subject to the tender includes concrete, drainage and excavation works as well as rock fortifications. Although the location of the work in question is in the same location and shows similarities in stone supply and transportation, it will not be the right approach to compare them with each other because it is not known under what conditions in the technical specification. Since the above-mentioned points are in accordance with Article 45 of the Public Procurement General Communiqué titled “Extremely low bid evaluation”, it has been concluded that the extremely low statement is sufficient. " has included a description.
In his statement regarding the extremely low bid inquiry of the bidder who left the tender; In 17.084 / K pose, he gave a price offer of 3,90 TL for "Stone Preparation", for this purpose Bor Beton Ürünleri ve Maden Ürt. and Paz. Ltd. Şti. the price offer was received from Bor Beton Ürünleri ve Maden Ürt. and Paz. Ltd. Şti. SMMM approved cost determination reports were submitted, and 0,30 TL was declared for the loading of the stone, and Oba İnş. Tic. and San. Ltd. Şti. and SMMM approved cost determination reports were submitted, a price of 13,50 TL was declared for stacked stone filling and Oba İnş. Tic. and San. Ltd. Şti. 15.006 / H1 (DLH) Trench Excavation (0-2 mt), 21.011 (BBF) Flat Surface Reinforced Concrete Formwork, 18.460 / 2 (BBF) Q200 PVC Drainage Beam Laying, 09.001 / 1 Cement Unloading, 09.003 / 1 Unit price list for Sand Gravel Loading and Unloading Figure poses, the bidder made a statement by adding profit to the unprofitable official prices of the Ministry of Public Works and other institutions, and that their explanations are in accordance with Article 45 of the Public Procurement General Communiqué. It was understood that the transaction established by the tender commission was not contrary to the legislation.
For the reasons explained, in accordance with the 4734 clause of 65, this decision shall be notified or notified.
The rejection of the appeal complaint in accordance with paragraph (c) of the tenth paragraph of Article 54 of the said Law;